Kill Your Television
Not like this is new news, but every day I’m reminded more and more that traditional television (and with it, traditional advertising) is dying.
For me, it started around 2002 with Netflix, which killed any need I had for cable TV. Why pay for HBO or Showtime when I could rent The Sopranos, Six Feet Under and Sex and the City and gorge myself for hours in one sitting? The years since then have produced an avalanche of other factors. This past year, an EyeTV and an HD antenna on our roof meant that my husband and I could snag HD-quality shows off the airwaves, record them to a MacMini (hooked up to a projector) and watch them whenever we felt like it. Add ABC and NBC’s websites (and my discovery that the Firefox extension AdBlock Plus zapped ads inside the ABC episode player) and there was no reason at all to give a rip about stupid ol’ networks and their stupid ol’ commercials.
Hulu sealed the deal, allowing me instant access to shows like It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia (not to mention discovering oldies-but-goodies like The Bob Newhart Show and full-length films like Ice Age for my kid). While they have ads that are immune to the powers of AdBlock Plus, they are relatively unobtrusive and don’t require any “click to continue” nonsense. The frosting on the cake is the growing number of self-produced and online-distributed shows like 3Way and We Need Girlfriends, the latter of which has been picked up by CBS. (We can only hope it enjoys a better fate than the pile of suck called Quarterlife, which NBC picked up and then promptly dropped when it suffered worse ratings than the XFL.)
And how about the glorious day when I discovered Best Week Ever was a free podcast that I could sync to my iPhone along with TV shows I had purchased from iTunes? I haven’t experienced a boring airline flight since.
And yet, with all of that, the networks seem to be in utter denial about what’s happening. The CW made a huge gaffe this year when, in an attempt to “force” more viewers to watch Gossip Girl on the network, they decided not to make post-strike episodes available on their website. Presumably, this decision was made to get better ratings: the show was crazy popular on the CW site and iTunes, but not on the dusty old television. Surprise, surprise, pulling the full episodes from the site had almost no effect on ratings. After tasting the freedom of watching a show online whenever you felt like it, who the hell was going to sit down on the date and time the network decided and watch it on TV?!
Their decision was understandable in the sense that nobody seems to have figured out how to monetize online entertainment in the same way that they have on broadcast, and the CW presumably makes less when I buy the episode from iTunes than if I watch it on TV where they can sell ads. But how long can that last? Viewers aren’t flocking back to television; they are (like me) tossing their TVs ad snuggling up to their computers.
So, my big question — and maybe some media buyer out there can answer this for me — is why? How can this not translate into better revenues for online advertising, or some new model for monetizing the distribution of online entertainment? Especially considering how damn trackable and relatively cheap it is compared to a TV commercial? At some point, won’t the old model crumble under its own weight? And can’t we come up with something better than just aping the existing broadcast model of interrupting the show with X-second spots?
While I love to pick on the ad industry (and bite the hand that fed me: I was raised by a copywriter and a print project manager), I don’t argue that there has to be a way to pay for this entertainment. I’m willing to watch ads if I’m getting a show for free (except during Lost. Sorry, ABC.), and I’m willing to pay iTunes to have Mad Men at my fingertips. I’m not the kind of girl that has illicit late-night encounters with BitTorrent. But — all that being said — advertisers need to find a way to reach us without assaulting us (I’m looking at YOU, movie theaters! I paid for my damn seat, don’t make me watch a car commercial before the show. Or how about TBS and their ridiculous “pausing the show for an ad” trick? See, that’s what drives us into the arms of AdBlock Plus whenever we have the option!) and consumers need to be realistic about their expectations around what is free.
But, I know that it’s unlikely any of this will change. The genie is out of the bottle: I have to read ads in bathroom stalls and my neighbors are all trading pirated files on Limewire. But, it sure would be nice if we could call a truce and allow more on-demand access to entertainment while also fairly compensating the businesses and people that create it. In the meantime, I’ll just enjoy insane Nissan product placements while watching Heroes on NBC.com and wait for this all to shake out.
Tags: No Tags
July 31st, 2008 at 9:09 am
[…] hdinstallers.com wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptThis past year, an EyeTV and an HD antenna on our roof meant that my husband and I could snag HD-quality shows off the airwaves, record them to a MacMini (hooked up to a projector) and watch them whenever we felt like it. … […]
July 31st, 2008 at 9:26 am
[…] Original Interactive Marketing - MIMA Blog […]
August 4th, 2008 at 10:33 pm
Well, well, well. I was listening to MPR over the weekend and On The Media had a story about this very topic!
“…the most ambitious aspect of NBC’s Olympic plan might be its push to change the way advertisers pay TV networks for ads. NBC will use the Olympics to attempt to show the world that, despite gloomy reports for the future of the networks, their audience hasn’t abandoned them at all. They’ve just migrated to other platforms.
So, says, Grant Robertson, media reporter for Toronto’s Globe and Mail, NBC will be keeping meticulous track of the numbers of people watching the Olympics across all platforms, online, DVR, cell phones – and both people who still sit in front of the TV. And they’ll combine those numbers in a brand new way.”
It will be fascinating to watch this develop and see if and how it affects the future of advertising [cue futuristic music].
August 4th, 2008 at 10:34 pm
Son of a…
I meant to *link* to that On The Media story. Here it is:
http://www.onthemedia.org/transcripts/2008/08/01/02
August 5th, 2008 at 7:17 am
I visited your link and found it very informative.
Minnesota Treatment Centers
August 6th, 2008 at 10:01 am
Hulu is just the tip of the iceberg, there are many sites out there that provide far more selection (although they are often linking to videos with random chinese scrolling phrases and subtitles - or bad filming in theaters). Now, I get almost offended when a station doesn’t post shows on their website!
I think TV as it is now will always have a place - but for me its more channel surfing. There’s always the thrill of a Lost or Office party with friends when a new episode or season premiere or finale is going on…but I agree that many TV networks and entertainment companies are in denial about how most people are changing their viewing habits.
August 8th, 2008 at 4:07 pm
Agree that there are far more sites outside of Hulu, but as you mention there are quality (and copyright) issues with many of them. Part of what I wanted to express with this post is our responsibility as consumers to not expect that everything will be free, or ad-free. To me, that responsibility includes not consuming pirated material. I also prefer (as a consumer) knowing that I’m getting a high-quality version of the material (like Lost in HD on the NBC site) vs. a lower-quality version on YouTube. But, yeah, the number of options (both legal and otherwise) is far and wide and will only continue to grow!
August 10th, 2008 at 11:35 pm
Yeah, I’m a dork and I comment on my own posts. Whatever.
Anyway, found another interesting tidbit:according to New York magazine’s Daily Intel, The CW is going to start streaming Gossip Girl online again this season.
“As it turned out, illegal access to GG episodes increased by 45 percent when the CW stopped streaming it.”
Read the full article here:
http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2008/07/gossip_girl_returns_to_the_int.html
October 10th, 2008 at 10:12 pm
On October 5, 2008, the CW Network premiered a new drama from the creators of The Sopranos. The new show, called Easy Money, is said to be about a family who owns and operates a “high-interest loan†business called Prestige Payday Loans. It’s always great to see shows being produced in an effort to bring underrepresented cultures or things into the limelight; as long as it constitutes a fair and balanced portrayal of the subject matter at hand. However, by taking one look at the trailers for the new drama, as well as a few of the episode synopses, my biggest fear is that the premise for the show is based solely on vicious media stereotypes. With this in mind, think of the last time that you viewed a news story either online or on television news talking about the payday loan industry. Chances are the story you saw or read wove tales of “real†persons’ woes fueled by their getting bogged down in an “endless cycle of debt.†Worst of all, according to such “articles,†it all started when they needed to borrow money to fix their car or pick up the tab on another unexpected bill. Such stories are further proof that, for the sake of winning the ratings wars, news networks will latch on to and report only the juiciest, most scandalous aspects of any big story and completely ignore everything else. It seems as if the CW network is following suit in an effort to recover viewers lost during the Writer’s Strike. One, for instance, opens with the tag line, “for this family of loan sharks, money is easy.†Surely, it’ll be interesting to see whether or not the CW or the show’s creators learned what the industry is really about. Chances are, probably not.
Post Courtesy of Personal Money Store
Professional Blogging Team
Feed Back: 1-866-641-3406
Home: http://personalmoneystore.com/NoFaxPaydayLoans.html
Blog: http://personalmoneystore.com/moneyblog/
February 14th, 2009 at 9:03 am
[…] macmini | user-saved public links | iLinkShare 5 votesMacMini. At least part of it fits in the envelope>> saved by surfeando 5 days ago6 votesRumormill churning out new material - claims Apple will update almost everything in Sept.>> saved by JULIESloveslotr 5 days ago2 votesExternal Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac, MacMini, Power Mac G5 …>> saved by coty 14 days ago4 votesMy MacMini grows tired>> saved by iso10 21 days ago2 votesMacmini Intel Loepard Serverã®å†·å´>> saved by rplaw 21 days ago5 votesExternal Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac G5 Xserve …>> saved by iloveskaters6912 22 days ago1 votesMaking Final Archival Prints in Photoshop CS3 using an Intel …>> saved by rruane 29 days ago1 votesComment on BMW 128i vs Clubman S by Dave MacMini>> saved by LongClawz 34 days ago1 votesBest Price on External Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power …>> saved by electropublication 39 days ago6 votesKill Your Television>> saved by billkav 39 days ago6 votesMaccuff Mini Mounting Bracket F/attaching Macmini To Monitor/desk>> saved by marcioellobo 42 days ago5 votesDesktop PC’s are shrinking>> saved by rodoflight 44 days ago1 votesminiStackãŒv2.5 ã¨ã—ã¦ãƒªãƒ‹ãƒ¥ãƒ¼ã‚¢ãƒ«>> saved by moonlightsaffire 57 days ago4 votesPodCasting Setup v1>> saved by creeder 62 days ago3 votesMacMini Mods!>> saved by schmittexin 71 days ago1 votesiphone x macminiï¼»iphoneï¼½>> saved by matthewturkey 89 days ago4 votesHow Apple will takeover the living room>> saved by note 92 days ago4 votesAuction On External Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac …>> saved by camontuyu 94 days ago3 votesAdvice on setup required - MBP, MacMini, PowerBook, ACD, iMac>> saved by icosahedron20 97 days ago3 votesiphone x macminiã€iphone】>> saved by stcclibrary 100 days ago4 votesBUY External Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac G5 …>> saved by wardley 101 days ago2 votesiphone x macmini「iphoneã€>> saved by todashdarkness 102 days ago4 votesGeek Macmini !>> saved by karimally 104 days ago4 votesShiny new MacBook has usability problems>> saved by godot242 107 days ago2 votesExternal Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac G5 Xserve …>> saved by rappa14 109 days ago3 votesIntel Macmini パワーアップ>> saved by randomaze 109 days ago3 votesMom joins the Mac family>> saved by mdhooge 120 days ago1 votesBUY External Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac G5 …>> saved by enrico61 131 days ago2 votesColocation für MacMini, Tower und HE-Rechner>> saved by xstevenhotx 133 days ago3 votesMac mini: review>> saved by roelc07 133 days ago1 votesExternal Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac G5 Xserve …>> saved by meteorite 138 days ago2 votesAnd the winner is…>> saved by gregorymercer 140 days ago3 votesiPhone 3Gã€æœ€ä½Žæœˆé¡2990円ã§åˆ©ç”¨å¯èƒ½ã«>> saved by Uchiharichard2 149 days ago3 votesExternal Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac G5 Xserve …>> saved by jh200 150 days ago2 votesBusiness Housing (Tower, HE & MacMini) in Frankfurt>> saved by RWHITSON 153 days ago3 votesExternal Keyboard Skin for Apple iMac MacMini Power Mac G5 Xserve …>> saved by kidamazone 157 days ago1 votesMacMiniã€æµ®ã。>> saved by dashhuang 157 days ago2 votesbacking up …>> saved by Ferdster123 158 days ago4 votesMacã®ãªã‹ã§Windowsを飼育ã™ã‚‹>> saved by Coval 172 days ago4 votesThousands of Macs Heading Into Cruise Ships and Hotel Chains>> saved by Tihara 176 days ago […]